A few weeks ago, Heidi at Tried-and-True Cooking with Heidi posted a recipe that she called Old-School Peanut Butter Squares. The recipe caught my eye because it does not call for marshmallows (we like marshmallows, but they aren't always in the pantry). The only tweak I made was to substitute some of the sugar for a little honey (I love the taste of peanut butter with honey). I must say the treats were a big hit around here. With mom's packing school lunches these days, I thought it would be a good time to repeat Heidi's super simple and super tasty recipe.
1 cup light corn syrup1 cup white sugar (see note)1 cup peanut butter 5 cups crisp rice cereal Combine corn syrup and sugar in medium saucepan. Stir until well blended and cook on medium heat until boiling (stirring occasionally). Let boil for 30 seconds and remove from heat. Stir in peanut butter and mix until well blended. Stir in cereal and mix well. Pour into greased 9x13 pan. Lightly spray hands with cooking spray and press mixture into pan. Cool and cut into squares.NOTE: I removed 2 tablespoons of sugar and replaced it with 2 tablespoons of honey.NOTE: I let my syrup mixture gently boil for a full minute.NOTE: I found that you don't have to spray your hands with cooking spray when you press down the mixture. If you dampen your hands and just shake them dry for about 5 seconds, it does the same thing without making the treats greasy.SEE VIDEO TUTORIAL >>
Related Posts:
SUPER SOFT PUMPKIN COOKIES & A BABY MOOSE STORYThese little unassuming cookies are wonderful. They've been sitting on my counter all day and they are still so soft (almost cake like). The recipe ma… Read More
PEANUT BUTTER RICE KRISPIE TREATSA few weeks ago, Heidi at Tried-and-True Cooking with Heidi posted a recipe that she called Old-School Peanut Butter Squares. The recipe caught my eye… Read More
CHOCOLATE FUDGE & DULCE de LECHE TASSIESChocolate Fudge and Dulce de Leche TassiesAll Rolled Into One Gem of a Cookie PASTRY CRUST½ cup butter softened(1) 3 ounce package cream che… Read More
CRANBERRY SHORTBREAD BARSThis week, I have been trying out some new "goodie" recipes with the holidays in mind; I like to add a few new items to my standard cookie boxes every… Read More
CREAM CHEESE SPRITZ COOKIESSpritz cookies are one of the simplest cookies you will find and they come in many flavors. Our favorites are chocolate, butter and cream cheese. Trad… Read More
CHOCOLATE-PEANUT BUTTER FILLED COOKIESThere should be a warning attached to this recipe...do not eat these while they are still warm, because you won't be able to stop!! These chocolate sp… Read More
PEANUT BUTTER AND CHOCOLATE (and the cooking blah's)This is not my favorite time of year. We still have a little snow in the yard and everything is a sad shade of “dead vegetation brown” except for the … Read More
SHORTBREAD MELTAWAY COOKIES My Hubby has started a new hobby...wood turning and I couldn't be happier. I am quickly accumulating beauties like the piece below which is made out o… Read More
BAKE SALE BUTTERSCOTCH COOKIESI call this recipe "Bake Sale Butterscotch Cookies" because they are quick and inexpensive to make, they are something a little different and the reci… Read More
CLASSIC PECAN TASSIEAlmost everyone has their own favorite version of a pecan tassie, the classic Christmas treat. However, for those who don't, this is a great one. Peca… Read More
CLASSIC PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES I have been making this classic cookie for so long (and so often) that I no longer need a recipe. It has been my "go to" cookie for decades. It is sw… Read More
PEANUT BUTTER-OATMEAL-CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIESHAPPY HALLOWEEN FROM OUR NEIGHBORHOOD TO YOURS!! This cookie recipe has something in it for everyone...peanut butter, oatmeal & mini-chocolate chi… Read More
(TWIX COPYCAT) CHOCOLATE-CARAMEL-SHORTBREAD COOKIESA few days ago, I spotted an intriguing recipe on someones web page, however, in my haste I didn't take note of who's page it was (thank you to everyo… Read More
COCONUT-RUM SUGAR THINSThis quick and easy cookie is a real winner! Great for any occasion; it stays chewy for days (if they last that long).The coconut and rum extract is a… Read More
THE ULTIMATE (FILLED) PEANUT BUTTER COOKIEThese (crispy on the outside - creamy on the inside) cookies are a hit every time I make them. They are quick to make and delicious to eat, with a swe… Read More